Well, I didn't see the shows you guys saw, so first, let's consider that maybe someone's experience is an anomaly.
Now, to provide my basis of argument, I'll let you know I've seen about as many shows as a 24 year old can see. Yes, probably still a fraction of many on this discussion board, but I've caught an amazing amount of acts in a variety of environments. And not just 'newfangled young people stuff' either. I've seen Chicago, AC/DC, Fleetwood Mac, Beach Boys, Motley Crue, Van Halen--all kinds of stuff my parents took me to as a squirt. Some of the great performers of rock and roll.
I've seen great concerts and I've seen miserable concerts, but generally, most acts fall somewhere in between. I'm the picky type, honestly...and I'm not a complete local music apologist either in the company of my close friends. I've seen some really subpar performances from bands that get plenty of local praise, only to impress me at a later date. And, by the way, I'm pretty sure I know who you're talking about at the 'private showcase' and I've definitely felt very similarly about them before. But they've killed it other times.
Young Coyotes I really enjoyed, though--really cool musical ideas, powerfully performed. However, if I'm being honest, I felt their lack of instrumental variety wore a little thin by the end of the 35-minute (or so) set. But, timing problems?
Maybe I should have one of my band members chime in, but I'm an asshole about maintaining meter. I'm not terribly blessed with musical talent, but good rhythm is something I've always had to offer to bands I've played in. It's also something that really sticks out to me as a spectator, and I didn't notice anything detrimental about Young Coyotes. In fact, I had a smile on my face the entire time two weeks ago. The new songs were great and the Black Sheep had this spectacular, cavernous reverb engulfing every channel. Cave-rock, yeah!
We may be sharing a bill on the 5th of March and I know we're playing together on the 20th, so maybe I'll form a different impression, but right now? One of the better shows I've seen locally in a while.

